Charity Independent Examination And Audit Reports, And Thresholds - Charity Commission CC32

A practical guide to charity independent examination and audit reports of charity annual accounts, including thresholds, the difference between audit and independent examination, and how to find an auditor or independent examiner, with links to all the resources and Charity Commission guidance you'll need.

Charity Independent Examination And Audit Reports - Charity Commission CC32

A practical guide to Charity Commission CC32 - audit and independent examination reports of charity annual accounts. It includes thresholds, the difference between audit and independent examination, and how to find an auditor or independent examiner, with links to all the resources you'll need.  At the end are sections on how to prepare your charity annual accounts and file your annual return.

Charity Independent Examination And Audit Thresholds

If you annual income is £25,000 or more you will need to get your accounts checked.

You will need a full audit if you have:

  1. income over £1 million
  2. gross assets over £3.26 million and income over £250,000

The only exception is where the Commission has approved an independent examination of a particular year’s accounts instead of an audit.

Although unusual, your governing document, the Charity Commission, or a funder may also require an audit report. 

If the above do not apply, you will require an independent examiner's report instead. 

Independent Examination And Audit - Exemptions

If your income is under £25,000, the Charity Commission does not usually require audit or independent examination of charity's annual accounts.  Although unusual, there may be additional external scrutiny requirements.  A particular example is Parochial Church Councils.

Access All The Free Resources

Health check any area of activity in 30 mins, including finance, with access to the huge resource base of Charity Commission policy, and free guides, toolkits and organisations that will help you for free, and the Funding Finder online directory of charity grant funding.  

Fast, Simple And Everything Is Free.

To find the help and funding you need – Register Now

The Difference Between Independent Examination & Audit Reports

Being Scottish, the biggest difference is that an independent examination is much cheaper, but that's because it's less thorough.  Both are types of independent scrutiny, and provide  a report to the trustees

  • Independent examination - provides 'negative assurance'.  That is, checking that the accounts look correct and agree with the records, but assumes that the underlying records are correct. Charity Commission CC32 provides guidance on what an examiner must do and his or her role and responsibilities.
  • Charity audit - provides 'positive assurance', by also verifying that the underlying records are correct.  It's a far more in-depth process, takes a lot more time and needs to be conducted by a qualified auditor, so it costs more.

Both provide some, but not absolute, assurance the accounts are accurate and correctly compiled, but not that the charity is making good financial decisions, although a good auditor/examiner may well offer help and suggestions.  

Charity Independent Examiner Requirements & Reporting

An independent examiner must:

  • Be independent of the charity.  Independence means that the examiner must not be influenced, or could not be perceived to be influenced, by their relationships with the charity and its trustees.
  • Have the requisite ability and practical experience to carry out a competent examination.  Specifically:
    1. Income over £250,000 - a member of one of the accountancy bodies listed in the Charities Act 2011.
    2. income £250,000 or less - an understanding of accounting principles, accounting standards and the Charities SORP.
    3. income £250,000 or less and your charity has opted to prepare receipts and payments accounts - sufficient financial awareness, numeracy skills and relevant experience to carry out the work and make the judgements required. 

You can find full details of the Charity Commission requirements for independent examiners here.  if you need it, the independent examiner reporting template is here

How To Find An Independent Examiner Or Charity Auditor

Personally, I usually speak to sister charities, CICs, or small businesses in my local area.  If you don't know any, Google 'charities near me'.  Having someone local is useful and they'll be able to give you some sort of recommendation and an indication of cost.  If you're a small charity and know an accounting practice, you could always try asking if they'd carry out an examination pro bono.     

Charity Intelligence have a nationwide network of accountants and other finance professionals you can browse. The Association of Charity Independent Examiners also have a list and here's a list of charity auditors.  I have no commercial relationship with any of these organisations and, presumably, companies pay to be included on these lists. 

How To Choose An Independent Examiner Or Charity Auditor

  • Regulatory.  What the regulations require is the minimum you must meet.
    • A check, a qualified examiner, or an audit. 
  • Sector Experience.  Certainly, for an auditor, I'd always look for someone with charity sector experience, because charities have specific rules and regulations that don't apply to other organisations.  Good ones may offer more wide ranging advice and will make you aware of any regulatory changes you may need to know about. 
  • Cost.  If you don't require an audit, but are thinking about one, be clear what the benefits to you would be and that the additional cost would make this worthwhile.
  • Location.  Being local to you can be useful, particularly for visits to check your accounts and to meet the trustees. 
  • Other Services.  Some organisations provide clients with free access to webinars or training events, or similar.    

Whatever you choose to do, always shop around and, even if your current provider is delivering a quality service, it's good practice to retender every few years. 

Access All The Free Charity Resources & Free Funding Database

Find funders using the Funding Finder database and 50+ funder lists.  Health check your charity in half a day, access the huge resource base, including 100s of organisations that provide free help and resources, and achieve the Quality Mark.

Fast, Simple And Everything Is Free.

To find the help and funding you need – Register Now

How To Prepare Your Charity Accounts

Use this toolkit to identify what the Charity Commission needs you to do to prepare your annual accounts.  You may also find Charity Commission CC16 (Receipts and payments accounts pack) and CC17 (Accruals accounts pack - SORP FRS 102) useful. 

There is sometimes confusion between cash and accrual accounting - the difference is one of timing.  If you record income or expenses when you pay or receive money, it’s cash based accounting. If you do it when you receive a bill or raise an invoice, it’s accruals based accounting.  Often, small charities use cash based accounting and larger ones accruals. 

How To File Your Charity Commission Annual Return

For everything you need to know to prepare and submit your Charity Commission annual return and file your accounts, use this Charity Excellence guide

This Resource Doesn't Constitute Professional Opinion

I have worked in the sector at senior level for many years and hold an ACCA postgraduate qualification, but am not an accountant and no advice can be applicable to all organisations, in all circumstances, so this resource does not constitute professional opinion.  Essentially, I've summarised the wide ranging and detailed regulatory guidance and augmented this with my own experience and Internet research to create a layman's guide, with links to the source guidance. I hope you found it useful. 

The questions are phrased brilliantly - challenging how we prioritise our management time." Ecosystems Knowledge Network

Register Now